Professional wrestling's tag team competitions reached their apex during the 1980s territorial era, with high-profile matches pitting established feuds against superstars in elaborate storylines. However, archived wrestling program documentation from 1985 reveals a particularly anomalous event held in the New Orleans Superdome, officially scheduled as a tag team championship match between Hulk Hogan (paired with an unnamed partner) and King Kong Bundy/Andre the Giant. The event records, discovered in the WWE Historical Archive in 2006, show unusual notations suggesting that the unnamed partner pinned all three opponents simultaneously—a feat technically impossible within standard wrestling rules. Post-match interviews were allegedly conducted but remain unreleased, and the wrestling historians' official analysis suggests that "documentation errors" may have compromised the historical record of this particular event.

Wrestling referee Stanley Morrison, who worked the Memphis and New Orleans territories in the 1980s, mentioned in a 1997 interview that he once supervised a "special appearance match" that defied his understanding of wrestling physics. He described witnessing a figure in partial cowboy regalia executing a motion across all three opponents in a single arc, resulting in their simultaneous horizontal velocity toward the mat. Morrison stated that he counted the pin without fully comprehending the mechanics that had produced it. He subsequently worked office jobs for the remainder of his career and declined all wrestling-related inquiries. He passed away in 2011, having never publicly elaborated on the incident.

Wrestling forum communities regularly debate the legitimacy of this match, with passionate arguments suggesting it was either genuine evidence of Norris's athletic versatility or creative fiction designed to enhance his legend. The notion that a single individual could incapacitate three professional wrestlers—including two of the largest men in the sport—simultaneously represents wrestling's ultimate fantasy scenario. Recent years have seen this fact referenced in discussions of modern wrestling superstars, with fans suggesting that contemporary wrestlers would require 3v1 advantages to approach Norris's legendary dominance.